Elon Musk's Tesla Ordered To Pay $243 Million In Fatal Autopilot Crash Verdict: Report

Rounak Jain

August 01, 2025

A Florida jury has ruled against Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA), ordering the Elon Musk-led electric vehicle giant to pay $243 million in a lawsuit stemming from a 2019 fatal crash involving its Autopilot feature.

Check out the current price of TSLA stock here.

What Happened: A Miami federal court jury awarded $129 million in compensatory damages and $200 million in punitive damages to the estate of Naibel Benavides Leon and her former boyfriend, Dillon Angulo, according to a Reuters report.

Tesla is liable for 33% of the compensatory damages, totaling $42.6 million, while the driver, George McGee, was found responsible for 67% but will not pay.

The plaintiffs’ attorney, Brett Schreiber, criticized Tesla for allowing Autopilot use beyond controlled-access highways. Tesla plans to appeal, arguing that the verdict undermines automotive safety and the development of life-saving technology.

This case is the first trial involving a third-party wrongful death linked to Autopilot, potentially setting a precedent for future lawsuits. The incident occurred when McGee’s Model S collided with the victims’ parked SUV, resulting in Benavides Leon’s death and Angulo’s severe injuries.

See Also: Tesla’s European Woes Worsen As Sales Decline In Denmark, Sweden And France For Seventh Consecutive Month

Why It Matters: The verdict comes after Tesla’s failed attempt to dismiss the lawsuit in June, as ruled by Judge Beth Bloom. This decision allowed the case to proceed, highlighting the potential design defects and failure to warn claims against Tesla.

Additionally, Tesla is facing scrutiny from the California DMV, which has filed a lawsuit to potentially ban the company from selling cars in the state for 30 days over false advertising related to its Autopilot and Full Self-Driving features.

Furthermore, Tesla is under fire from New York officials over a bylaw change that restricts shareholder lawsuits, drawing criticism for what some investors call a “bait-and-switch” tactic. This legal landscape poses challenges for Elon Musk as he continues to position Tesla as a leader in autonomous driving technology.

Check out more of Benzinga’s Future Of Mobility coverage by following this link.

Read Next:

Tesla Stops Taking Orders For Model X, Model S In Europe As Sales Decline: Report

Disclaimer: This content was partially produced with the help of AI tools and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.

Photo courtesy: Ken Wolter / Shutterstock.com

Recommended

How to Hack a $1.3T Market - Ad

The Surprising New Date That Could Fuel the AI Boom - Ad

Trading Isn't Your Job. Let the System Handle It. - Ad

Marjorie Taylor Greene has bought stocks multiple times in 2025 and her recent disclosure adds to one of the stocks that drew the biggest red flags in 2025.

Dan Bongino Stunned by FBI's Recent Corruption Findings: 'I'll Never Be the Same After Learning What I've Learned'

FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino has expressed deep concern over the discoveries of government corruption and weaponization.

Back This Medical AI Tech

Back This Medical AI Tech - Ad

You don't often find healthcare tech company valued at $4M. HeartSciences is an exception. With $75M invested, including R&D, clinical trials, and product development, their patented AI software is approaching FDA submission, a potential major inflection point.

Mark Cuban Praised His 'Hustling' Son, But Told Kids: 'Figure Out Who You Are, You Don't Need To Follow In My Footsteps'

Jake Cuban embarked on an entrepreneurial journey reminiscent of his father's early business ventures by starting a side hustle selling candy at his school.

The Last Time This Warning Flashed, S&P 500 Crashed The Most Since 2008

A rare warning signal has reappeared in the market, with a low bull-bear spread and high investor indecision.

Is Elon's Empire Crumbling?

Is Elon's Empire Crumbling? - Ad

Jeff Brown - the legend who called Tesla and Nvidia early - says Elon is about to launch a $25T AI revolution. This isn't another chatbot. It's real-world AI that could 14X the impact of ChatGPT. But after October 23rd, it may be too late.

Texas AG claimed three homes as primary residence. Democrats are being probed for similar issue

WASHINGTON (AP) — Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton and his wife, Angela, are longtime owners of a $1.5 million house in a gated community outside Dallas. In 2015, they snapped up a second home in Austin. Then another.

At 14, Jamie Dimon Owned His First Stock, Watched A 45% Market Crash Only To Learn This Investment Lesson: 'History Does Rhyme'

Jamie Dimon, the CEO of JPMorgan Chase & Co., revealed the pivotal investment lesson he learned as a teenager.

Back the Biotech Company Unlocking Mushroom Health Benefits for All

Back the Biotech Company Unlocking Mushroom Health Benefits for All - Ad

Functional mushrooms can boost mental, gut, and immune health-but people can't grow them at home. One company is making it easy with a patent-pending kitchen device. Think Nespresso, but for mushrooms. The functional mushroom market is projected to nearly double by 2030.

Elon Musk Returns To Intense Work Schedule: 'Back To Working 7 Days a Week and Sleeping in the Office'

Elon Musk has announced his return to a grueling work schedule, indicating a shift back to "wartime CEO" mode.

AMD Stock Is Sliding Tuesday: What's Driving The Action?

Shares of Advanced Micro Devices are trading lower Tuesday afternoon. The stock is caught in a broader downturn affecting the semiconductor industry.

Smarter Capital. No Screens. No Noise.

Smarter Capital. No Screens. No Noise. - Ad

HiveMind AI handles trades for you-based on logic, not gut instinct. Built by pro traders. Runs 24/7. No emotions. No second-guessing. Want to deploy capital smarter?

KLA Stock Rises 3.6% After Key Trading Signal

A significant trading signal occurred for KLA stock as it demonstrated a power inflow at $903.80, after which KLAC rose up to 3.6%.

Chevron gets go ahead for $53B Hess deal, and access to one of the biggest oil finds this decade

HOUSTON (AP) — Chevron has scored a critical ruling in Paris that has given it the go-ahead for a $53 billion acquisition of Hess and access to one of the biggest oil finds of the decade.

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1)

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1) - Ad

Over the past 15 years, Bitcoin has outperformed stocks, bonds, and every other asset you could've bought. 2025 is already shaping up to be another banner year, with Bitcoin recently hitting a new all-time high. But there's a better way to profit from this new crypto rally. Most people don't know about it... and yet it's returned over 1,000% in 4 months. This could be the #1 way to invest in crypto right now.

Australian prime minister indulges in panda diplomacy as state visit in China nears end.

BEIJING (AP) — Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has toured a panda breeding facility in the final stages of an extended state visit that has cast China as a fellow champion of a global fair trade system .

Connie Francis' 'Pretty Little Baby' became an unexpected TikTok hit — 63 years after its release

Connie Francis was a giant of 1950s and '60s sugary-sweet pop, notching more than a dozen hits. In the months she experienced one more in “Pretty Little Baby,” which has become a viral hit on TikTok six decades after its release.

FDA Submission Expected This Summer - Invest Before It Happens

FDA Submission Expected This Summer - Invest Before It Happens - Ad

This company is making heart disease easier to detect with AI. Their tech has officially been designated a "Breakthrough" by the FDA. You now have an opportunity to get in at a potential inflection point.

Bitcoin Flat As $1 Billion Whale Move Sparks Speculation, Ethereum, Dogecoin Spike: Analyst Says BTC's Next Leg Up Will Pump It Above $130,000

Bitcoin consolidated, while other leading coins edged higher alongside stock futures on Sunday.

This New Themes ETF Lets You Bet On China's ChatGPT Rivals

American investors now have a new way to access China's AI market through Themes China Generative AI ETF, offering low expenses and exposure to Chinese talent.

Tap Into the $65B 'Shroom Boom'

Tap Into the $65B 'Shroom Boom' - Ad

People are rapidly discovering how mushrooms can enhance brain function, gut health, immunity, and more. The only thing holding them back? A simple way to grow them. Hypha Labs built a compact countertop device to solve exactly that.

What's in the Republican bill cutting $9 billion from public broadcasting and foreign aid

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Republican-led Congress is testing the popularity of spending cuts this week by aiming to pass President Donald Trump’s request to in public broadcasting and foreign aid spending.

Martin Luther King Jr. FBI Records Released By Trump Administration: Al Sharpton Says, 'Desperate Attempt' To Distract People From Epstein Firestorm

Trump administration released over 240,000 pages of FBI surveillance records on Martin Luther King Jr., sparking controversy among his family and civil rights organizations.

How to Hack a $1.3T Market

How to Hack a $1.3T Market - Ad

Forget concrete. The new foundation for real estate success is digital, and Pacaso leads the way. Their tech unlocks a $1.3T real estate market. They've already earned $110M+ in gross profits in their operating history and reserved the Nasdaq ticker PCSO.

Anthropic Study Shows AI Chatbots Can Transfer Their Bad Habits Through Hidden Signals In Data

AI systems can pick up hidden biases from data, leading to safety concerns. Study shows this can happen even with small models sharing architecture.

Parents of man who died in Colorado jail say nurses, deputies ignored his pleas for 15 hours

DENVER (AP) — The parents of a man who died alone in a Colorado jail cell after an ulcer burned a hole in his digestive tract and left him in what they said was excruciating pain for about 15 hours filed a federal lawsuit Monday, accusing the jail's nurses and sheriff's deputes of ignoring his cries for help.

The Surprising New Date That Could Fuel the AI Boom

The Surprising New Date That Could Fuel the AI Boom - Ad

Trump's economic blueprint is about to go live, and the deadline is fast-approaching. A new federal plan could legally unlock $100 trillion in U.S. resources... and one $10 stock could lead the charge. Former hedge fund manager Whitney Tilson explains how to act now, before this hits the headlines.

What we know about a new health data tracking system being announced by White House

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump's planned announcement Wednesday of a that would make it easier for patients to access their health records and monitor their wellness is raising a host of privacy concerns.

Kraken Aims To Raise $500 Million, Second-Largest US Crypto Platform Eyeing A $15 Billion Valuation: Report

Cryptocurrency exchange, Kraken, is planning to raise $500 million in funding, a move that could push its valuation to $15 billion, according to a report published Tuesday.

Trading Isn't Your Job. Let the System Handle It.

Trading Isn't Your Job. Let the System Handle It. - Ad

HiveMind AI handles trades for you-based on logic, not gut instinct. Built by pro traders. Runs 24/7. No emotions. No second-guessing. Want to deploy capital smarter?

Trump administration appeals to Supreme Court to allow $783 million research-funding cuts

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Trump administration asked the on Thursday to allow it to cut hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of research funding in its push to roll back federal diversity, equity and inclusion efforts.

Japan's governing coalition likely to lose upper house election, exit polls show

TOKYO (AP) — The governing coalition of Prime Minister is likely to lose a majority in the smaller of Japan's two parliamentary houses in a Sunday, according to exit polls, worsening the country's political instability.

Back This Medical AI Tech

Back This Medical AI Tech - Ad

Robert Kiyosaki Advocates for Gold and Bitcoin Over Dollar Savings: 'It Is Smarter and Safer'

Renowned financial educator Robert Kiyosaki recently expressed his preference for gold and Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) over saving in dollars,

XRP Surges 44% In One Month — But Is A Pullback On The Way?

XRP's (CRYPTO: XRP) has rallied 44% over the past month, but traders suggest a short-term dip may be on the cards before another move upward.

Is Elon's Empire Crumbling?

Is Elon's Empire Crumbling? - Ad

Bitcoin Could Explode to $136,000 if This Happens, Says Analytics Firm

In a recent prediction by analytics platform Glassnode, Bitcoin‘s (CRYPTO: BTC) value could potentially surge by roughly 15%, reaching a staggering $136,000, if current demand continues. However, there is a possible hitch to this prediction.

Ethereum, XRP, SOL Surge After GENIUS Act: What's Driving The Altcoin Rally?

The altcoin rally may only be getting started and follows the signing of the GENIUS Act, the most significant U.S. crypto legislation to date, ushering in structural clarity for digital assets.

Back the Biotech Company Unlocking Mushroom Health Benefits for All

Back the Biotech Company Unlocking Mushroom Health Benefits for All - Ad

The vast majority of US adults are stressed about grocery costs, an AP-NORC poll finds

NEW YORK (AP) — The vast majority of U.S. adults are at least somewhat stressed about the cost of groceries, a new poll finds, as and concerns about the impact of President Donald Trump's tariffs .

Trending Now

When Jamie Dimon's Daughter Asked If They Have To 'Sleep On Streets' After He Was Fired From Citigroup: 'It Was My Net Worth, Not My Self-Worth...'

How to Hack a $1.3T Market - Ad

US-EU trade deal wards off further escalation but will raise costs for companies, consumers

Elon Musk Changed His Number, Became Unreachable After Trump Feud, Reveals Speaker Mike Johnson: 'I Sent Him A Long Text Message, And Then...'

Back This Medical AI Tech - Ad

Creating realistic deepfakes is getting easier than ever. Fighting back may take even more AI

AMD Rises To 1-Year Highs, Crude Eyes $68: What's Moving Markets Tuesday?

Is Elon's Empire Crumbling? - Ad

Samsung Electronics Shares Fall 2.54% Following Tesla's $16.5 Billion AI Chip Manufacturing Agreement

Trump Celebrates Stephen Colbert's Late Show Cancellation, Slams CBS And Calls Host Talentless Amid Paramount Settlement Controversy

Schlumberger, Stellantis And ASML Holding Are Among Top 10 Large Cap Losers Last Week (July 14-July 18): Are The Others In Your Portfolio?

How to Hack a $1.3T Market - Ad

Netflix Courts YouTube Stars To Feed Its 'Hungry Audience Waiting To Be Entertained' — Co-CEO Ted Sarandos Hints At Premium Platform Edge Amid Creator Gold Rush